Skip to Main Content (access key 1)
Skip to Search (access key 2)
Skip to Search GO (access key 3)
Skip to comments (access key 4)
Skip to navigation (access key 5)
Skip to top of page (access key 6)
Thursday, November 15, 2007 | Reason : Religion as Child Abuse | print version Print | Comments

Document African Crucible: Cast as Witches, Then Cast Out

by Sharon LaFraniere

Reposted from:
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/15/world/africa/15witches.html?_r=1&th&emc=th&oref=slogin

UIGE, Angola — Domingos Pedro was only 12 years old when his father died. The passing was sudden; the cause was a mystery to doctors. But not to Domingos's relatives.

They gathered that afternoon in Domingos's mud-clay house, he said, seized him and bound his legs with rope. They tossed the rope over the house's rafters and hoisted him up until he was suspended headfirst over the hard dirt floor. Then they told him they would cut the rope if he did not confess to murdering his father.

"They were yelling, 'Witch! Witch!'" Domingos recalled, tears rolling down his face. "There were so many people all shouting at me at the same time."

Terrified, Domingos told them what they wanted to hear, but his relatives were not appeased. Ferraz Bulio, the neighborhood's traditional leader, said seven or eight captors were dragging Domingos down a dirt path to the river, apparently to drown him, when he intervened.

"They were slapping him and punching him," he said. "This is the way people react toward someone accused of witchcraft. There are lots of such cases."

Mr. Bulio is right. In parts of Angola, Congo and the Congo Republic, a surprising number of children are accused of being witches, and then are beaten, abused or abandoned. Child advocates estimate that thousands of children living in the streets of Kinshasa, Congo's capital, have been accused of witchcraft and cast out by their families, often as a rationale for not having to feed or care for them.

The officials in one northern Angolan town identified 432 street children who had been abandoned or abused after being called witches. A report last year by the government's National Institute for the Child and the United Nations Children's Fund described the number of children said to be witches as "massive."

The notion of child witches is not new here. It is a common belief in Angola's dominant Bantu culture that witches can communicate with the world of the dead and usurp or "eat" the life force of others, bringing their victims misfortune, illness and death. Adult witches are said to bewitch children by giving them food, then forcing them to reciprocate by sacrificing a family member.

But officials attribute the surge in persecutions of children to war — 27 years in Angola, ending in 2002, and near constant strife in Congo. The conflicts orphaned many children, while leaving other families intact but too destitute to feed themselves.

"The witches situation started when fathers became unable to care for the children," said Ana Silva, who is in charge of child protection for the children's institute. "So they started seeking any justification to expel them from the family."

Since then, she said, the phenomenon has followed poor migrants from the northern Angolan provinces of Uige and Zaire to the slums of the capital, Luanda.

Two recent cases horrified officials there. In June, Ms. Silva said, a Luanda mother blinded her 14-year-old daughter with bleach to try to rid her of evil visions. In August, a father injected battery acid into his 12-year-old son's stomach because he feared the boy was a witch, she said.

Angola's government has campaigned since 2000 to dispel notions about child witches, Ms. Silva said, but progress comes slowly. "We cannot change the belief that witches exist," she said. "Even the professional workers believe that witches exist."

Instead, her institute is trying to teach authority figures — police officers, teachers, religious leaders — that violence against children is never justified.

The Angolan city of Mbanza Congo, just 50 miles from the border with Congo, has blazed a trail. After a child accused of witchcraft was stabbed to death in 2000, provincial officials and Save the Children, the global charitable organization, rounded up 432 street children and reunited 380 of them with relatives, the witchcraft report stated.

Eleven fundamentalist churches were shut down because of reports of child exploitation and abuse. Eight Congolese pastors were deported. Villages formed committees to monitor children's rights. The authorities say the number of children who are abused or living on the streets dropped drastically.

Uige, about 100 miles to the south of Mbanza Congo, is another story. Surrounded by lush green hills, it is a cluster of mud-clay settlements around crumbling shops pockmarked by bullet holes. In this region, said Bishop Emilio Sumbelelo of St. Joseph's Catholic Church, persecution of children is rising.

"It is very, very, very common in the villages," he said. "We know that some children have been killed."

His church runs the town's only sanctuary for children victimized as witches, a shelter barely bigger than a three-car garage. Thirty-two boys, including Domingos, occupy bunk beds stacked a foot apart, their few clothes stashed in boxes underneath. No shelter exists for girls.

Since July, all newcomers have been turned away. "Children come here to ask for protection, but we have no space," the bishop said. "To date, we have not found any special way to fight against this phenomenon."

Many boys describe pasts of abuse, rejection and fear. Saldanha David Gomes, 18, who lived with his aunt until he was 12, said she turned on him after her 3-year-old daughter fell ill and died.

After, he said, his aunt refused to feed him and bound his hands and feet each night, fearing that he would take another victim.

A neighbor finally warned him to flee. "I am not a witch, and I was not a witch," Saldanha said. "But I had to run away because they were threatening to kill me."

Afonso García, 6, took the shelter's last empty cot in July. "I came here on my own because my father doesn't like me and I was not eating every day," he said matter-of-factly.

After Afonso's mother died three years ago, he moved in with his father. His stepmother, Antoinette Eduardo, said she began to suspect that he was a witch after neighborhood children reported that he had eaten a razor. Besides that, she said, "he was getting thinner and thinner, even though he was eating well."

Under questioning, she said, Afonso admitted that a male relative had visited him in his dreams, demanding that he kill a family member. Afonso denies ever confessing to witchcraft.

What unfolded next is typical of many cases here. Afonso's relatives turned to a traditional healer for a cure.

The healer, João Ginga, 30, wears a fur-collared leather jacket and works out of what he calls a hospital — a cramped mud-walled room. "If someone has a bad spirit, I can tell," he said one recent morning as clients waited on a bench. "We treat more than a thousand cases a year."

With such a busy trade, Mr. Ginga said, he could not remember Afonso's case. Afonso's aunt, Isabella Armando, said her family gave Mr. Ginga $270 in cash, candles, perfume and baby powder to treat Alfonso.

Mr. Ginga performed some rituals, put a substance in Afonso's eyes that made him sob in pain and pronounced him cured, she said. But Afonso's father and stepmother, the only relatives who could afford to care for him, did not agree, and expelled him from their household.

"I pitied him, and I still pity him because he was living in the streets," the stepmother explained. "But we were afraid."

Mr. Ginga is hardly the only healer here who claims to cure child witches. Sivi Munzemba said she exorcised possessed children by inserting a poultice of plants into their anuses, shaving their heads and sequestering them for two weeks in her house.

Moises Samuel, director of the provincial office of the children's institute, said he was concerned not only about traditional healers but also about a bevy of churches with soothsayers who claimed to exorcise evil spirits and drew crowds even on weekdays.

Once a soothsayer or healer brands a child a witch, child welfare specialists say, even the police often back away.

Officers kept Domingos, the boy who was suspended from a rafter, for one night at the station house, then sent him home, said Mr. Bulio, the settlement's traditional leader. They never investigated Domingos's uncle, who Mr. Bulio said led the attack.

"Of course it was a crime," Mr. Bulio said. "But because it is witchcraft, the police do not take any responsibility."

Domingos, now 15, insisted that he said he was a witch only to save his life. But even his 32-year-old mother, Maria Pedro, disbelieves him.

Ms. Pedro is obviously fond of Domingos, her oldest child. She beams over his academic progress and worries about further attacks by his relatives, should he leave the shelter.

Still, she said, she suspects that he was bewitched into murder. "It must be true because he himself confessed," she said, eyeing Domingos carefully across a table in her two-bedroom house.

At that, Domingos stood up and walked swiftly from the house. Ten minutes later, he reappeared in the doorway, his face red and splotchy. "Mother, from this day on, I am no longer your son," he declared fiercely.

Ms. Pedro wordlessly watched him go. "I just don't know why Domingos got so angry," she said later.

For more information on this story, see
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/4677969.stm

To see images, go to
http://www.nytimes.com/slideshow/2007/11/14/world/1114-WITCHES_index.html

Comments 1 - 10 of 10 |

Reload Comments | Back to Top | Page Numbers

1. Comment #88199 by elfinabout on November 15, 2007 at 8:44 am

 avatarPeople sometimes ask me why I get so incredibly heated about religion. Why it matters to me what myth, fantasy or folklore some or other idiot believes. Why it's relevant. Why I'm so fiercely and passionately of the belief that we should no longer tolerate religion of any sort. Why we should shout, slap and shake people out of their ignorant, destructive, childish stupor with vigour and commitment.

It's about education. It's about dignity. It's about our own humanity. It's about being personally accountable for our actions.

I invite those people to read the above - one of many, many examples of similar behaviour the world over. Right now. Here. Today. In the 21st century. And then never ask me those questions again.

Other Comments by elfinabout

2. Comment #88200 by BaronOchs on November 15, 2007 at 9:17 am

 avatar
Afonso's aunt, Isabella Armando, said her family gave Mr. Ginga $270 in cash, candles, perfume and baby powder to treat Alfonso.


The most evil people in a situation like that are the people who make money out of it. This situation is fuelled by poverty and as a result they give even more of their scarce resources away to charlatans.

Other Comments by BaronOchs

3. Comment #88206 by Mango on November 15, 2007 at 10:53 am

 avatar
"Even the professional workers believe that witches exist."


This makes the entire culture sound "backwards" but replace "witches" with "Jesus" and it puts it into context. It's an endemic lack of reason, there and here.

Other Comments by Mango

4. Comment #88220 by Ultraviolet G on November 15, 2007 at 11:56 am

elfinabout>

(adopts Alistair McGrath voice)

"..but what I would like to say is, that isn't OUR religion.."

Of course not Mr. McGrath, YOUR religion is obviously the correct one, not like these poor fools.

Does anyone else think that the "not my religion" crowd are, not racists per se: that's completely the wrong insinuation and I do not accuse them of it for a second- but extemely chauvinistic and provincial and bourgeoise?

Other Comments by Ultraviolet G

5. Comment #88291 by the izz on November 15, 2007 at 8:27 pm

 avatarToo right Mango!

Other Comments by the izz

6. Comment #88292 by Veronique on November 15, 2007 at 8:30 pm

 avatarComment #88199 by elfinabout

Thank you!! I have been saying for months on these comment threads that we can no longer turn blind eyes to religion of any sort, anywhere.

My intense anger, at reports like these, is too deep for tears. Containing that anger and redirecting it into useful, productive actions is very difficult when you live in a country where religious tolerance is the norm and no one takes any notice of people like me who are just seen as eccentric. It gives me the shits.

I know why I am angry. Short of going to Angola and spending the rest of my life trying to deprogram people and avoid being killed myself, what the f***k can I do? My frustration levels, when reading reports like these, goes into overdrive. And I feel so impotent to do anything that can institute change.

Yes, I know it's the 21st century, but the people who are described in the above article, are subject to witchdoctors (control freaks) and the f*****g Catholic and others churches who send their 'missionaries' over to these places in order to inculcate yet another set of ridiculous beliefs and sugar-coat their 'message' with 'conditional' aid. It drives me bonkers!!

I understand how you feel
V

Other Comments by Veronique

7. Comment #88364 by Yaweh on November 16, 2007 at 8:10 am

 avatarReligious people say, "Religion isn't the problem; human nature is the problem."

I agree. Humans are too superstitious and gullible and consequently do a number of horrible things.

So let's teach people to be skeptical. No one should believe supernatural claims without corroborative evidence.

Other Comments by Yaweh

8. Comment #88387 by arogop on November 16, 2007 at 12:02 pm

 avatarPeople do things like this then wonder why they are poor and why the world turns its back on them. How do you help someone who is that naive.

We can educate the children but the old are probably lost forever.

Other Comments by arogop

9. Comment #89019 by Garnok on November 19, 2007 at 1:59 pm

Ultraviolet G said:
Does anyone else think that the "not my religion" crowd are, not racists per se: that's completely the wrong insinuation and I do not accuse them of it for a second- but extemely chauvinistic and provincial and bourgeoise?


How about elitist? They discriminate by claiming that they have a sophisticated belief system and anyone who does not have the same one or something similar, and that may include those who simply lack an integrial part of the belief system, is somehow deficient or incapable to reaching "rational" conclusions. But those that cannot do so are not to be denigrated or abused, they are to be pitied.

Other Comments by Garnok

10. Comment #93063 by Sunglasses on December 2, 2007 at 5:10 am

Veronique said:

Yes, I know it's the 21st century, but the people who are described in the above article, are subject to witchdoctors (control freaks) and the f*****g Catholic and others churches who send their 'missionaries' over to these places in order to inculcate yet another set of ridiculous beliefs and sugar-coat their 'message' with 'conditional' aid. It drives me bonkers!!

my response:
The catholic church does not give out "conditional aid" to folks in need.
The aid given to these poor children has no strings attatched. In fact, you can call up your local catholic charities right now- tell them you are an atheist and need help. No problem, and no need to convert either.
What basis do you have to say the aid is conditional? I would like to simply take your word on it- but forgive me for not doing so.
Its pattently false.
If aid was conditional- dontcha think Benedict would have asked that muslim who seeked asylum because he wanted to become a christian- dontcha think Benedict would have said: sure, if you become a catholic? He is NOT a catholic. Benedict got the man out anyway! Gimme a break with the conspiracy theories!

Other Comments by Sunglasses
Reload Comments | Back to Top

Comment Entry: Please Login

Register a new account

Username:

Password:

Send a letter to the editor of the original media outlet.
letters@nytimes.com