Skip to Main Content (access key 1)
Skip to Search (access key 2)
Skip to Search GO (access key 3)
Skip to comments (access key 4)
Skip to navigation (access key 5)
Skip to top of page (access key 6)
Friday, March 23, 2007 | Science : Earth Sciences | print version Print | Comments

Document Sea floor records ancient Earth

by BBC, Jonathan Fildes

Thanks to Ian for the link.

Reposted from:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/6479289.stm

sea floor
The ancient sea floor was discovered in southwest Greenland

A sliver of four-billion-year-old sea floor has offered a glimpse into the inner workings of an adolescent Earth.

The baked and twisted rocks, now part of Greenland, show the earliest evidence of plate tectonics, colossal movements of the planet's outer shell.

Until now, researchers were unable to say when the process, which explains how oceans and continents form, began.

The unique find, described in the journal Science, shows the movements started soon after the planet formed.

"Since the plate tectonic paradigm is the framework in which we interpret all modern-day geology, it is important to know how far back in time it operated," said Professor Minik Rosing of the University of Copenhagen and one of the authors of the paper.


"Sea floor is not normally preserved for more than 200 million years"
Minik Rosing


Professor John Valley, a geologist at the University of Wisconsin, Madison described the work as "significant" and "exciting".

"If these observations are substantiated it will be a significant line of new evidence indicating that plate tectonics was active and familiar as early as 3.8 billion years ago," he said.

"That really is an important conclusion."

Crack and spread

Plate tectonics is a geological theory used to explain the observed large-scale motions of the Earth's surface.

The relatively thin outer shell of the planet is composed of two layers: the lithosphere and the asthenosphere.

pillow lava
Ancient pillow lavas are preserved in exquisite detail

The lithosphere - made up of the outer crust and the top-most layer of the underlying mantle - is broken up into huge plates; seven major plates and several smaller ones.

These float above the asthenosphere and move in relation to one another.

Today, oceanic crust is created at plate boundaries known as mid-ocean ridges, where magma rises from the asthenospehere through cracks in the ocean floor, cools and spreads away.

See how plate tectonics works

As it moves away from the spreading centre towards the edges of the oceans it becomes cooler, denser and eventually starts to sink back into the mantle to be recycled.

"Sea floor is not normally preserved for more than 200 million years," said Professor Rosing.

Most is destroyed at subduction zones, such as those found along the edge of the Pacific Ocean, where oceanic crust plunges under the buoyant and long-lived continental crust.

Water world

However, in certain circumstances, fragments of the sea floor known as ophiloites are preserved when they are scraped on to the land.

This exceptional process typically occurs when continental crust begins to be sucked into a subduction zone, clogging the system.

"It goes down into the subduction zone until the buoyancy of the continent arrests the process of subduction," explained Eldridge Moores, emeritus professor of geology at the University of California, Davis.

old rocks
"You can actually recognise features that formed in a couple of minutes, 3.8 billion years ago"
Minik Rosing


"The continent then pops back up, preserving a little bit of the overriding wedge of oceanic crust and mantle that was on the overriding plate."

Ophiolites are found today in Cyprus and Oman and show a distinctive structure.

At their base, crystalline rocks preserve the top layer of the mantle. Above, "fossilised" magma chambers give way to a layer of stacked vertical pipes, known as sheeted dykes.

These represent the conduits through which magma is extruded onto the sea floor as pillow lavas, bulbous lobes of basaltic rock that form when lava cools quickly in contact with water.

Racing rocks

The rocks analysed in Greenland are found in an area known as the Isua Belt, a zone of intensely deformed rocks in the southwest of the island that geologists have pored over for decades.

The ophiolite structure was mapped between outcrops covering 4-5km (2.5-3 miles) and shows the correct sequence of layers found in an ophiolite, except the lowest mantle portion.

"You can actually recognise features that formed in a couple of minutes, 3.8 billion years ago - a quarter of all time - and you can actually go and touch them with your hand," said Professor Rosing.

greenland
The rocks are found in the Isua Belt, in southwest Greenland

Crucially, they show well preserved sheeted dykes and pillow lavas, clear evidence to many that these are the ancient remains of sea floor created by processes seen today.

"What this tells you unequivocally is that the process of sea-floor spreading that we observe today appears to be present in one of, if not the, oldest sequence of rocks on Earth," said Professor Moores. "That is a significant milestone."

In particular, it pushes back the oldest known evidence of plate tectonics by at least 1.3 billion years and gives scientists clues to the processes that formed the surface of the Earth today.

Although the structures and processes that led to their formation would be similar to the modern era, they would not be exactly the same.

The young Earth was much hotter than now, and as it shed heat, it put many of the tectonic processes into overdrive.

"If you had plate tectonics you probably would have had more plates, moving faster, and they probably would have been thinner," said Professor Moores.

The rate of recycling of oceanic crust would therefore have been even quicker than today, making the fact that the rocks in Isua are preserved at all even more extraordinary.

"These fragments are extremely rare," said Professor Rosing. "It's just very exciting when you get one of these glimpses when you can look back nearly four billion years in time."

plates
- Magma rises from the asthenospehere at mid-ocean ridges
- New crust cools and spreads away from ridge
- Denser oceanic crust begins to sink back into the mantle at subduction zone
- Melting of slab creates volcanoes on overlying continental crust

Comments 1 - 9 of 9 |

Reload Comments | Back to Top | Page Numbers

1. Comment #27283 by neander on March 23, 2007 at 5:52 pm

 avatarGood science, and more data for fundies to deny.

Other Comments by neander

2. Comment #27303 by MIND_REBEL on March 23, 2007 at 8:01 pm

 avatarCan't wait for the fundies to claim it's all a lie, and threaten to place scientists in jail.

Other Comments by MIND_REBEL

3. Comment #27322 by karlJ on March 24, 2007 at 1:26 am

 avatarThe fundamentalist selective mind will focus on some insignificant detail, misconstrue it, and conclude that it's proof of their views.
The pictures obviously shows that the earth is flat. Well mostly flat, only some small bumps can be seen. And if so, how could there ever have been water up to the top of the mountain. The water must very quickly have flowed over the edge of the earth.

Other Comments by karlJ

4. Comment #27329 by BicycleRepairMan on March 24, 2007 at 4:08 am

 avatarHello all, Just registered :) I'm sort of embarrassed to make this my first post, but I saw these Neal Adams Videos, and I got very curious, (and skeptical) about this "Expanding planet" thing (http://www.nealadams.com/nmu.html), Unfortunately, I don't have much knowledge about planet cores and such, and I cant seem to find out exactly why this theory cant be right? Could anyone point me to somewhere or some book or something that shoots this theory down, or is there anything to it?

Other Comments by BicycleRepairMan

5. Comment #27333 by cheshirecat on March 24, 2007 at 5:03 am

In a word no. You can tell simply from the language. It is too highly coloured and full of rhetoric. You will note the similarity between it and the language of the conspiracy theorist in the way it makes assertions.If you say a thing and then have to add "This is fact!" you clearly have not proved it or indeed its relavence to the arguement that you are making. This is someones pet theory based in fact on a theory that is actually competed with plate techtonics (theory of the subduction of one plate under another) for a while but ceased to be taken seriously. Its main exponent who was a serious scientist (unlike neale adams who draws cartoons for a living) is now dead. He was Samuel Warren Carey.

Other Comments by cheshirecat

6. Comment #27337 by BicycleRepairMan on March 24, 2007 at 5:50 am

 avatar"If you say a thing and then have to add "This is fact!" you clearly have not proved it or indeed its relavence to the arguement that you are making"

Well its certainly something I'd be likely to say about evolution to a creationist, Does then the colour of my language say anything about the truth of what I'm saying? I dont think so. What I'm looking for is exactly why Subduction is more likely than expansion.. Wikipedia ,as you surely will bash me for using :), says its because they could not find any evidence that mass can possibly be "generated", which I guess is the answer I'm looking for..

PS. Wiki also says the scientist was Samuel Carey, and not Warren.

Other Comments by BicycleRepairMan

7. Comment #27463 by g-21-lto on March 24, 2007 at 6:06 pm

BicycleRepairMan -- there are several good lines of evidence for subduction occuring. One would be the existence of Wadati-Benioff Zones, which are dipping, ~planar zones of deep earthquakes (too deep to be explained by much other than unusually cold material, given the heat and relative lack of rigidity of material normally found at those depths), are best explained by the subduction of slabs of cold, rigid oceanic lithosphere. Wiki has a page on Wadati-Benioff zones if you want to check it out.

Also, the volcanic arcs associated with supposed subduction zones erupt lavas that have chemical signatures best explained by the presence of water at depth during the melting process. This water is most easily supplied by the loss of water from a subducting oceanic slab as it descends and heats up.

Other Comments by g-21-lto

8. Comment #198374 by OnanTheLibrarian on June 23, 2008 at 4:55 pm

"The ophiolite structure was mapped between outcrops covering 4-5km (2.5-3 miles) and shows the correct sequence of layers found in an ophiolite, except the lowest mantle portion."

"Crucially, they show well preserved sheeted dykes and pillow lavas, clear evidence to many that these are the ancient remains of sea floor created by processes seen today."

This is quite interesting given past portrayals of Archean crust. The pillow lavas don't mean much (Hawaii is not on a spreading ridge), but the ophiolite sequence and sheeted dykes seem to nail it down. Is there any igneous environ that will produce sheeted dykes and pillow lavas without commensurate subduction?

If plate tectonics occurred in similar fashion as today except at differing rates and thicknesses, then we have new perspective on post-collisional tectonics through examining unroofed batholithic Archean terranes.

Other Comments by OnanTheLibrarian

9. Comment #198385 by TeraBrat on June 23, 2008 at 5:25 pm

Bicycleman,

There's also the evidence from the sea floor itself. The earths magnetic field reverses every (I can't remember how many thousand years), the ocean floor holds evidence of the ridges and subduction zones because in some places you'll have one extreme polarity or the other and in other places you'll have none. The lack of polarity is the result of two oposing polarities sitting on top of each other and canceling each other out. On the other hand sometimes you'll get fresh magma with the same polarity overlaying old volcanic material and then the polarity is strong. If you're really interested in this why don't you go to the library and check out a geology book. Most basic geology books aren't too hard to understand.

Other Comments by TeraBrat
Reload Comments | Back to Top

Comment Entry: Please Login

Register a new account

Username:

Password: