Skip to Main Content (access key 1)
Skip to Search (access key 2)
Skip to Search GO (access key 3)
Skip to comments (access key 4)
Skip to navigation (access key 5)
Skip to top of page (access key 6)
Tuesday, October 3, 2006 | Reason : Religion as Child Abuse | print version Print | Comments

Document Surviving 'Jesus Camp'

by Josh Timonen

JC1"Raise your hand if you think that God can do anything!"

Pastor Becky Fischer throws her arm into the air as an example while darting her eyes back and forth over the children in the audience. She yells in a fake high-pitched voice like a sleazy, overly animated kid's show host and waits for them to imitate her answer. In one aisle a mother lifts the arm of her disinterested son, no more than 8 years old.

That, in a nutshell, is the whole problem.

I almost walked out of Jesus Camp during several scenes; it was that hard to watch. As I listened to conversations around the theatre before the film, I was pleased to find myself in a fairly secular group. Not much of a surprise, considering we're in Hollywood. I stopped and wondered how the opening nights were in fundamentalist Christian towns such as Colorado Springs, Colorado.

Jesus Camp is a straightforward documentary, with no narrator or fancy cutting to present an opinion. The footage really does speak for itself. The film follows a group of children born into Evangelical Christian families as they prepare for and later attend the "Kid's on Fire" camp in Devil's Lake (I'm not making this up), North Dakota.

We meet a young boy in an oversized t-shirt who is lounging in front of the television at home. He's watching a "Creation Adventures" video for children, and with a commanding baritone voice it falsely instructs that the earth was formed 6,000 years ago by you-guessed-who. Thankfully, in my theatre this received a roaring round of laughter. The narrator makes a joke about how 'some people say' we came from 'slime,' and he puts on a ridiculous face as he holds up his two hands covered in a silly green goop. We later see this boy's mother looking through a 3-ring study binder at the dinner table, quizzing her son on what to say if someone tries to tell him that global warming is real(?!?). He knows the answer to this one, and with a smile tells his mother how he would reply: the temperature has only risen half a degree over some recent time period, and that this isn't a big deal. It was as if he was doing his nightly homework, with his mother at his side. I sort of missed what the boy specifically said. I had already blown a gasket and was yelling at the screen after the ridiculous global warming question the mother had asked - And from some 3-ring study binder no less!

Later we meet another camp attendee, a little girl who loves dancing. She is ashamed of when she sometimes dances "for the flesh" and has to correct herself, because everything she does must be for God.

At the church we see Pastor Becky Fischer in action with two boys (one was the boy watching the "Creation Adventures" video), recruiting them for the camp in the hallway with phrases such as "Right on, guys!" and "Totally cool!" Pastor Becky asks the boys if they plan on going to the camp, and they are. She tries out some other young trendy phrases in a high, affected voice, and gives them both a hug. Watching this I found myself growling out loud with anger like a dog after the mailman. My friend began elbowing me to keep it down.

Before camp begins, there is the blessing of the empty chairs, the electricity, and a PowerPoint presentation. It was much-needed comic relief, and my theatre laughed together for a moment.

The camp begins and it is pure madness. One of the first points of business is to condemn every child's favorite "warlock". Pastor Becky explains that "had he been in the Old Testament, Harry Potter would have been put to death!" (Thank goodness we've got that straightened out).

The children are all so eager to please, and this element of the film is the most difficult for me. If the adults decided to hand out the special Kool-Aid at this camp, the children would all unquestionably partake. With arms in the air, they are 'instructed' on how to let the spirit take over their bodies and speak in tongues. The children imitate. Many of them cry. Some fall to the ground and shake on the floor in what looks like an epileptic seizure. More cry. I wanted to cry with them, or more accurately for them. This all looked very unhealthy, I could only imagine what it was doing to them psychologically. I had the striking thought that this was all completely unforgivable. These adults, no matter their intentions, were performing horrific acts of mental child abuse.

Beck FischerThen comes the guilt, and mountains of it. "A lot of you say you're Christians, but how many of you are leading two separate lives?" Pastor Becky lays it on thick over the PA. She leads the children on through ideas of what they might be sinfully doing at school with their friends, and how they should be ashamed of themselves for it. I considered vomiting into my drink cup. She asks the children to gather around her and reach out their hands if they wish to be cleansed of these newly uncovered sins. Their cleansing source: A 20 oz. bottle of Nestlé-brand water poured over their grouped hands. Talk about product placement! There is of course more crying. There is more of me yelling at the screen, and more of my friend elbowing me in embarrassment.

They bring in a life-size cardboard cutout of President Bush in front of a big American flag, and the children are instructed to bless him and speak in tongues for him (or perhaps at him, I'm not exactly sure how this is supposed to work). Everyone performs as directed.

Suddenly, I was shocked to find a sense of relief wash over me. "Don't worry," I thought, "This is all a dream that you've had before! This is the one where the crazy Christians are with you on an airplane that is about to crash, and then Natalie Portman tells you-" No, wait, this is really happening! Can it possibly be?

LIFE Tape A 'Pro-Life' speaker visits the camp and explains how "God doesn't care about how small the baby is, it is still a person and a soul, even if it's just protoplasm..." he pauses to pan the young crowd with a cartoon-ish, bug-eyed smile before delivering his punch line: "...whatever that is!" Some in the theatre laughed, and some screamed. Things had become so unbelievable that the audience was just making whatever sounds were possible in their collective state of shock. The 'Pro-Life' man passed around a boxed set of plastic fetuses at different stages of development (do they sell these at Christian Supply stores?!). He then placed red gaffe tape with the word 'LIFE' written on it over each child's mouth in preparation for their protest in front of the US Capitol Building. I had to step back for a second. They are placing gaffe tape over a child's mouth, and the child is then persuaded to interpret this as a positive, meaningful experience. 'Let the church decide what goes in place of my personal thoughts and voice.' It's a sad metaphor for how these children are kept from thinking for themselves, and a sad irony how their 'LIFE', the only one they'll ever have, is truly what they are missing out on by accepting these dogmatic restrictions.

The sermons are rife with politics, and Pastor Becky leads the children in chilling chants such as "One nation under God!" and "Righteous Judges!" She preaches of war and the mission for their "key generation." She asks if they would lay down their lives for Jesus, and I'm sure you can imagine the children's eager response. As Pastor Becky later explains to the interviewer,

"I want to see young people who are as committed to the cause of Jesus Christ as the young people are to the cause of Islam. I want to see them as radically laying down their lives for the gospel as they are over in Pakistan and Israel and Palestine and all those different places... Excuse me, but we have the truth!"


No need to decipher her statements, no need for clever video cuts to accentuate the parallels. She spells it out for everyone, and it's jaw droppingly crystal clear through a megaphone. Let's call it religious fundamentalism, Coke and Pepsi.

Ted HaggardThe film even makes a quick visit to Ted Haggard's New Life Church in Colorado Springs, Colorado, just in case you were able to keep your lunch down this far into the film. In his sequel appearance to 'The Root of All Evil?' Ted is as creepy as ever, speaking directly to the camera as they attempt to film one of his mega-sermons. "If you try and use any of this I'll sue you!" he says perhaps half-jokingly, followed by an expected laugh from his flock. Ted even gets in his little sound byte about some people 'calling children animals.' He yelled this same phrase at Dawkins and his film crew in 'The Root of All Evil?' while chasing them away from the church in his pickup truck, and I wondered how frequently he replays that confrontation over in his mind.

'Jesus Camp' speaks without commentary like an ice pick to the heart and mind. In the United States we are in the presence of a dangerous and powerful Evangelical Christian movement that runs from local churches all the way to 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. Unless a person is steeped in such fundamentalism, I think viewers will come away from 'Jesus Camp' with an extreme sense of urgency for rational organization and action against this spreading virus. Maybe the film can shed light on the horrible indoctrination of these poor children. Some of them will escape their parent's religion, but too many will stay to repeat the memetic cycle with another generation of eager and impressionable young boys and girls.

We can always walk out of the movie theatre, but Ted Haggard, Becky Fisher, President Bush and millions of Evangelicals will be waiting for us in the real world, and how we handle their rising brand of fundamentalism will likely shape our nation and the world for generations to come.

Watch the trailer on apple.com

Visit the official 'Jesus Camp: The Movie' website

View the list of theatres showing 'Jesus Camp'

YouTube.com clips of 'Jesus Camp'



Comments 51 - 64 of 64 |

Reload Comments | Back to Top | Page Numbers

51. Comment #4627 by Randy Ping on November 5, 2006 at 12:35 am

Humbug. Where is the evidence for your gods?
Nowhere.
As an American, I am sick of the lies that religion tells and sells. And I am sick of superstition ruling the laws of my country instead of reason. It's time to grow up and put the imaginary friend away, children.
So stop with the "persecuted majority" BS. If you people could make a good argument and provide a single shred of evidence, I'd have never renounced faith.
But you can't. And when Somebody like Dawkins or Sagan has the guts to point that out, you all cry foul.
STop playing martyr and learn to face reality.

52. Comment #4632 by Youssef51 on November 5, 2006 at 12:57 am

Franklin:

An old song goes:

Fairy tales
Can come true
It can happen to you

Except for one thing. Fairy tales have not come true yet and they are very, very unlikely to come true any time soon.

You believe in your supreme spirits, some people believe in ghosts, others in unicorns, still others in the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

You are welcome to your beliefs, I wish you all the best. Just please don't try to impose your ridiculous daydreams on me, either directly or indirectly.

Also, please avoid indoctrinating small children in your nonsense as they have not yet developed the immune response needed to fight off your infection. Religious indoctrination of kids is abusive.

53. Comment #6771 by Anonymous on November 15, 2006 at 2:33 pm

hehe i guess you just cant convince some people that their sky fairy is a myth despite the evidence. its hard to accept faith and stupidity and religious heritage are stronger than science and rationality.

54. Comment #7991 by Ben on November 20, 2006 at 4:56 am

Nice site!
http://xlyywvnu.com/hxfd/yyfu.html">My homepage | http://qihytvzq.com/gdpy/pygv.html">Please visit

55. Comment #12982 by CrimsonSun on December 14, 2006 at 8:11 pm

Watch Jesus Camp Movie at:

http://www.atheistnation.net/index.php?p=36

Other Comments by CrimsonSun

56. Comment #17849 by Homo economicus on January 17, 2007 at 3:30 am

 avatarAs a secularist I think the freedom to believe is a fundemntal human right, but that faith does not have a special privledge within society nor is it desirable for it to have such a place.

As a humanist, it is important that people can reason for themselves. With children, it is learning the skills and analytical ability which is important. No one has the right to force their opinions on anyone, with children this is especially so.

Blatantly this Jesus camp is indoctrination and the impact on children highly questionable to the point that child abuse may not be too strong a word. I would be just as opposed if these things happended in an atheist camp.

I would be shouting with Josh in the cinema.

Other Comments by Homo economicus

57. Comment #29795 by Aaron SF on April 4, 2007 at 7:09 pm

 avatarThis article caught me. Not because of the horrendous abuse the kids are being subject to, that was all too familiar.

What caught me was the fact that this was being called abuse.

I was one of those kids, and I can testify that this is not isolated at all. I grew up in San Diego, California and the religious movement there is down-right scary.

But when I was a kid I didn't think... "Oh I'm being abused." Y'know what I thought?

I thought "Gee, I hope God thinks I'm worthy enough to make me a martyr some day."

That's right, I hoped that God in his infinite wisdom would find me fit to be MURDERED to make a point to other people.

Even though I've known for some time that all that stuff was twisted and seriously damaging, I didn't, until reading this article, actually comprehend that it WAS child abuse. That making a kid think they are evil to the core and need to repent for whatever that evil is (they might have no clue, but children have good imaginations, they can come up with something)... it's sadistic!!!

Not only should adults KNOW better, they should be fighting this kind of abuse.

It's a rape of the mind! What's the point of "protecting" children from violence or sexual content, and then turning around and doing this to them?

Is there a morality rating for Churches? This church is CHMA, don't send your children here unless you want them to be seriously F'cked up?

And as a side note, it doesn't matter how that woman meant what she said, it matters how the kids took it. That's why you have to watch what you actually do and say, not what you intend to mean.

Other Comments by Aaron SF

58. Comment #56520 by Aammy on July 16, 2007 at 5:31 am

You ppl are scary. Hmmm sorry but three thing's come to ming, Waco , Nikes and Kool aid.I am so glad my child will never be in your hands. Who knows what you would brain wash her about. But thats your life. I will just be on the look out for your type, and if someone wants to come to me and try to talk to me about god ....... Yeah ill tell them to just walk away. You preach nonsense. I sure hope ppl have called children services on your group. But Ill add, no one here on Earth is here to judge anyone else. Thats God's job. So if ppl dont agree with you ..... Oh well.

Other Comments by Aammy

59. Comment #62112 by Mysturji on August 8, 2007 at 8:02 am

 avatarMeerkat (post 27) wrote:
"I just think some compassion and sensitivity would be in order. Especially for anyone in the audience who is still an evangelical. As a former evangelical, I felt bad hearing the laughter. I can only imagine how my mother, my aunt, and other of my family members would feel."

Ridicule is the only appropriate response to the ridiculous.
Our right to free speech outweighs your right to not be offended.
What about those kids' right not to be subjected to psychological abuse?

Other Comments by Mysturji

60. Comment #94235 by dweebs on December 5, 2007 at 4:13 am

"I've found God! " (Quote by Anonymous)

He was in the crack behind my sofa!

Other Comments by dweebs

61. Comment #94726 by Madonna's Stardust on December 6, 2007 at 10:53 am

Listening to the movie clips on You Tube right now. (I'm at work so can't really watch them properly.)

*Shudder* - that just about sums up my reaction to the child abuse, hatred and indoctrination portrayed in this fascinating documentary.

Kind of reminds me of horror stories about satanic cults - perhaps the film should be remade substituting the word satan for god and vice versa. These people should give thought to what they are REALLY worshiping here......

Creepy stuff.....

Other Comments by Madonna's Stardust

62. Comment #154050 by evanmati on April 2, 2008 at 1:07 pm

christianity is big big business.

saying you represent god or the bible made Dobson about 150 million USD last year.

Robertson made 450 million USD last year.

all tax exempt so they don't support education or other social programs.

Science is not a religion.

Science is making an assumption and seeing if empirical experience supports that assumption.

if it does it gets raised to a new level of acceptability. until it is disproved or not. If it is, it is thrown away like many false assumptions.

Comte's book Positivism is great at explaining what science is. Science is not a belief system nor is it a religion. Science is a method of learning and a method of logical development.

simple minds will try to make everything as simple as they are.

I was an alter boy for 5 years and was brainwashed with that stuff. I am sorry i wasted thousands of hours of my life.

I can show at least 70 c0ntradictions in the "word of god". like can gay men have anal sex and beget children? Not as far as i know. Homogenisis does not exist.

Do we come from adam and eve? yes as i was taught anyway. they had two sons. kane and able.

so how did all of us come about? so from the very begining of that book of myths to the very end, it is embarrassing i had not noticed all that crap before.

i think if you get used to hearing lies as the truth every sunday and everytime you open the book you will be well trained for beleiving the sophisticated lies of politicians and pr people. in that way religion is a great political tool/weapon.

I think christianity is a sickness and if i was in power i would tax religion and if it was a fundamental religion i would triple tax it until it was no longer fundamentlist.

on the pulpit my pastor is still calling iraqi oil - "our oil"

A new bumper sticker out there.

"Don't believe everything your mind tells you"

To all you religofascists out there, enough is enough.

I have a book listing all the christian owned companies and i won't buy any thing or service form these douchebags. and i was raied christian. can you imagine the rage a freethinking american must feel.

wither douche bag religionists.

WDBR

Other Comments by evanmati

63. Comment #154096 by osric90 on April 2, 2008 at 3:51 pm

I am an athiest and films like this, and fall from grace annoy me greatly. But when people see films like this or hear things about individuals from religions, they automatically assume that every person in that religion is the same. Muslims are not all terrorists and Chrsitinas are not all fundamentalists.

A good friend of mine was recently talking to me and the conversation made it on to religion. We are both athiests, the only difference is that he looks down on people with religions and I don't. But he said something interesting, athiests do not believe in God, but you can't give something a name and say it doesn't exist. No you can touch God, appropriatly or not, you can see him or hear him, but if you name him he is there.

And you can't mock someone for belief, we all believe in something. Atheist usually have a lot of belief in a sports team, this could be counted as your religion. Belief is unique to every person in the world, so don't mock because you have a tiny mind closed to everything but what you see.

Other Comments by osric90

64. Comment #178597 by Sage on May 11, 2008 at 5:06 pm

 avatarWhere are these moderate Christians??

I confess what did impress me was the sheer energy and confidence of many of these kids involved.
Maybe if their interests were channelled into something more real and fulfilling like science or the arts, other than being fed such dangerous mind rotting garbage.

Other Comments by Sage
Reload Comments | Back to Top

More Comments: First | Previous | 1 2

Comment Entry: Please Login

Register a new account

Username:

Password: