Skip to Main Content (access key 1)
Skip to Search (access key 2)
Skip to Search GO (access key 3)
Skip to comments (access key 4)
Skip to navigation (access key 5)
Skip to top of page (access key 6)
Thursday, February 21, 2008 | Science : Earth Sciences | print version Print | Comments

Video The Lava Lizard's Tale

Richard Dawkins

This is the first of 3 tales to be posted. They were written immediately after The Ancestor's Tale was completed, and would have been included if Richard had visited the Galapagos Islands before the book was published.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=AMmPauwXxic

Quicktime Small (426x240, 34.8 MB) | Quicktime Large* (720x480, 81.5 MB) | Audio Only mp3 (3.5 MB)
Filmed & Edited by Josh Timonen

* Quicktime Large version is anamorphic, so it may appear too skinny if played in the browser. It is recommended that you download this file first, and then play it in the QuickTime player

This article was written while Richard Dawkins was on an earlier trip to Galapagos, and the footage seen here was shot on a later trip. This tale was originally posted at The Guardian website.

TRANSCRIPT:

A guide at the Natural History Museum stated confidently that a particular dinosaur was 70,000,008 years old. When asked how he could be so precise he replied, "Well it was 70 million when I started this job, and that was eight years ago." The evident experience of Valentina Cruz, our wonderful Galápagos naturalist guide, suggests that I must add a similar margin to the estimate of 100 years that she gave us for the age of the black lava fields on the island of Santiago. The exact date of the great Santiago eruption is not recorded, but it definitely happened on one particular day in one particular year around 1900. I shall call it SV day (Santiago volcano day). I need to seem as precise as the museum guide, although the exact date doesn't matter. Perhaps it was January 19 1897, 100 plus eight years before my visit to the island.

SV day was one day in the late 19th century, a day on which, elsewhere in the world, somebody's grandfather was born at some particular hour. Somebody else died. A moustached young man in a straw boater met his true love for the first time and was never the same again. Like every day that has ever been, it was a unique day. Every second of it. It also was the date of the great Santiago volcano, the one that made the lava fields that I walked this January in the company of lava lizards, Tropidurus albemarlensis, although I knew it only when they moved and betrayed their camouflage.

Lava lizards are pretty much the only things that do move over these barren fields of black, clinker-ringing rock. And as they do so their splayed hands are feeling - though they do not know it - the fingerprints of past time. Fingerprints? Past time? Wait, that is the theme of the lava lizard's tale.

Santiago was one of the four Galápagos islands on which Charles Darwin landed in 1835, and it was the only one where he spent any time, camping for a week while Captain Fitzroy took the Beagle to fetch fresh supplies. Darwin called it James, for he and his shipmates used the English names of all the islands: the evocative Chatham, Hood, Albemarle, Indefatigable, Barrington, Charles and James. He and his small camping party had trouble finding a clear spot to pitch their tent, so thickly did the land iguanas carpet the ground. Today there are no land iguanas left on Santiago. Feral dogs, pigs and rats did for them, although there are still plenty of land iguanas on other islands of this iconic archipelago, while the closely related marine iguanas abound on all the major islands including Santiago.

The black lava fields of Santiago are an unforgettable - almost indescribable - spectacle. Black as a female marine iguana (of course the simile really should go the other way) the rock is called rope lava, and you can soon see why. It is drawn out and plaited in twisted ropes and pleats, folded and gathered like a black silk dress, coiled and whorled in giant fingerprints. Fingerprints, yes, and that brings me to the point of the lava lizard's tale. As the lizard scuttles over the black lava of Santiago it is treading the fingerprints of history, rolled out by the sequence of particular events that tran-spired, minute by minute, on one particular day late in Darwin's century, marking the minutes of that day, the day of the Santiago volcano.

There cannot be many other ways to see, laid out before you, a complete history, second by second, of one particular day, more than a century ago. Fossils do the same thing but over a much longer time scale. The molecules of a fossil are not the original molecules of the animal that died. Even fossil tracks, like those Mary Leakey found at Laetoli, don't really do it. It is true that Laetoli shows you the exact places where two individual Australopithecus afarensis (those diminutive hominids carrying chimpanzee brains around on human legs), perhaps a mated couple, placed their feet during a particular walk together. There is a sense in which these footprints are frozen history, but the rock that you see today is not as it was then. That couple walked in fresh volcanic ash which later, over thousands of years, solidified and compacted to make rock. The lava ropes and pleats of Santiago, those giants' fingerprints, are still composed of the very same molecules that were frozen into precisely those positions, only a century ago. And the time scale over which the distinct ropes and pleats were laid down is a time scale of seconds.

Tree rings do it on a time scale of years. Where the whorls of lava fingerprinting are laid down second by second, and fossils are laid down by the millions of years, each tree ring marks exactly one year. Thick rings or thin label good growth years or poor and, because every sequence of half a dozen years or so has its own characteristic pattern of good and poor years, the patterns can be recognised, again and again in different trees, as labels of particular clusters of years. Old trees and young trees show the same fingerprints so, by counting rings and daisy-chaining the patterns from increasingly ancient wooden relics, archeologists can compile a catalogue of fingerprints outspanning the longest-lived tree.

Something similar can be done with sediment patterns laid down on the sea bottom and revealed in cores of mud taken up in deep sampling tubes. And, over the longer time span of hundreds of millions of years, the named strata of the geological series are, in their own way, fingerprints of time. What is so remarkable about the lava fields of Santiago is that these fingerprints were set out on the timescale that we humans deal with every second of our lives, the time scale of musical notes, the time scale of an artist's brush, the time scale of everyday actions and the stream of human thought.

This is a real thought for a surreal landscape. And the Galápagos islands are replete with images that could have come straight from a surrealist's canvas. A tiny desert island off Santa Fe (Barrington to Darwin) looks fit for Man Friday except that instead of palm trees there are giant cactuses. As if the Arizona desert had been transplanted into an azure sea; no surrealist could have done it better. And what are sea lions doing in the Arizona desert, to say nothing of shocking pink flamingos, equatorial penguins, or flightless cor morants earnestly hanging their impotent, stubby wings out to dry? As for the large flounder that I saw when snorkelling off North Seymour Island, it was pure Salvador Dalí. Changing colour to match the corals over which it slid like an oval carpet, I would certainly not have spotted it if Valentina had not gracefully dived to point it out to me. It was only later that my wife compared the flounder to the flowing, bending watch of a Dalí painting. And wasn't that very painting, the one with the bent watches, called The Persistence of Memory ? Not a bad title for the lava fields of Santiago, scuttling ground of the Galápagos lava lizards.

Reality, if you go to the right place, and see it in the right way, can be stranger than a surrealist's imagination. No wonder Darwin drew his early inspiration from these enchanted islands.

· Richard Dawkins's book The Ancestor's Tale, is a Chaucerian pilgrimage to the evolutionary past. The pilgrims are living creatures, and their tales are used to illustrate some general principles of evolution. This essay would have been included in the book if the author had written it after, instead of before his personal pilgrimage to the islands.

Comments 101 - 112 of 112 |

Reload Comments | Back to Top | Page Numbers

101. Comment #132975 by HarryHUK on February 25, 2008 at 1:36 pm

Viewed it a bit late,but that was intriguing,powerful stuff.

Other Comments by HarryHUK

102. Comment #133852 by Richard Dawkins on February 27, 2008 at 12:06 am

Richard Morgan:

What would music inspired by the fleas sound like?
http://richarddawkins.net/article,2303,Add-another-flea-to-the-list,RichardDawkinsnet

Something to make them seem ridiculous, pathetic, desperate?

How do you do it, by the way? Do you improvise at an electronic keyboard, and have the computer record what you do, then edit it? I have no conception of how this kind of thing is done, but I am extremely impressed.
Richard D

Other Comments by Richard Dawkins

103. Comment #133863 by Incredulous on February 27, 2008 at 1:43 am

Richard M,

I like your music. It even distracted me from the subject of the audios. May not be a good thing but you certainly make a pleasant sound.

Other Comments by Incredulous

104. Comment #134558 by eoinc on February 28, 2008 at 1:53 am

"What would music inspired by the fleas sound like?

Something to make them seem ridiculous, pathetic, desperate?"

I immediately thought of Ein Heldenleben by Strauss (Richard, not Johann). He depicts the life of a hero figure, by which he means himself, and his stuggle with his critics. If you haven't heard it before, you should really listen to it, it's superb music.

It's a single-movement symphonic poem, written in a very lengthy sonata form. The first subject, grand and sweeping and majestic (and in the hero key of Eb major) depicts the hero, who boldly announces his arrival and, with a very dramatic series of pauses and a single monumental imperfect cadence, awaits a response from the world.

The second subject is the critics, represented by sniping, twittering, incoherent woodwinds, verging on atonality.

There follows a domestic scene where the hero's wife, represented by a solo violin, alternately cajoles and nags the hero, before amorous feelings get the better of them both.

And then there is the famous "battle scene", where the hero directly confronts his critics and defeats them in what sounds like open warfare... oh, I could go on about this all day...

Other Comments by eoinc

105. Comment #134560 by eoinc on February 28, 2008 at 1:55 am

Wikipedia is rather more coherent than I am:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ein_Heldenleben

Other Comments by eoinc

106. Comment #134562 by Steve Zara on February 28, 2008 at 1:58 am

 avatarComment #133852 by Richard Dawkins

Something to make them seem ridiculous, pathetic, desperate?


I was tempted to reply "Don't hold back, Richard. Tell us what you really feel!"

But perhaps even stronger language would be inappropriate, albeit accurate.

I would add other adjectives: confused, ignorant, frightened, and, of course, deluded.

Other Comments by Steve Zara

107. Comment #158065 by Richard Morgan on April 10, 2008 at 3:33 am

 avatarBecause music is a universal language, apparently.

So, I leave you with this:



http://www.myspace.com/morgansoriginals



Goodbye, and thanks for all the fish.

Other Comments by Richard Morgan

108. Comment #158092 by GBile on April 10, 2008 at 4:12 am

 avatarRichard Morgan,

When you talked about 'the Bile and hatred on the RD-site' (terminology reused by David Robertson) in your comment in the FCOS-environment, I was startled. I always tried to keep my 'GBile' remarks on the topics covered by RD-net as suave as I could. Hatred is not a word in my vocabulary.
You seem to be saddened by what you read and it appears that I am listening to your 'Farewell music' at the moment. If you really feel that you have to depart, then so be it.
Your 'music-site' is bookmarked though.

Other Comments by GBile

109. Comment #182480 by sophia_mr on May 20, 2008 at 8:14 am

 avatarHm. This reminds me... can anybody tell me if Neil deGrasse Tyson has a column in Natural History magazine? I know he has one, I'm just not sure wich magazine

Other Comments by sophia_mr

110. Comment #182894 by mcgmelo1 on May 21, 2008 at 5:14 am

I really appreciate those lectures ( and all books...), and I guess that the general audience should feel honoured for such "dedication" to a so necessary effort, that is, of course, too valuable.

Prof. Richard Dawkins is really having success in his job, and success that will endure...

Other Comments by mcgmelo1

111. Comment #182895 by black wolf on May 21, 2008 at 5:17 am

 avatarsophia_mr,
Hm. This reminds me... can anybody tell me if Neil deGrasse Tyson has a column in Natural History magazine? I know he has one, I'm just not sure wich magazine


January 1995, ongoing
Author of column titled "Universe" for Natural History magazine.
from Neil's home page:
http://research.amnh.org/~tyson/cv.php#Magazine_Columns

Other Comments by black wolf

112. Comment #183198 by sophia_mr on May 21, 2008 at 2:01 pm

 avatarThanks so much, darling. I can't believe I was so absent minded as to not think of checking his site. Dhur!

Other Comments by sophia_mr
Reload Comments | Back to Top


Comment Entry: Please Login

Register a new account

Username:

Password: