Skip to Main Content (access key 1)
Skip to Search (access key 2)
Skip to Search GO (access key 3)
Skip to comments (access key 4)
Skip to navigation (access key 5)
Skip to top of page (access key 6)
Friday, August 3, 2007 | Reason : Wingnut News | print version Print | Comments |

Document Islamic creationist group launches glitzy, global blitz

by Yigal Schleifer

Reposted from:
http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0803/p01s10-woeu.html

Thanks to Richard Prins for alerting us to this article

A household name in Turkey, the 'Foundation for Scientific Research' is now distributing its books — published in 59 languages including Chinese and Swahili — to 80 countries.

On a recent afternoon inside Istanbul's busiest subway station, a young man beckoned commuters into a subterranean "fossil exhibit" full of skulls and insects dating back millions of years.

But this was no mainstream scientific display. One colorful poster advertised the "myth" of the evolution of the horse. Another, displaying a flying pterodactyl, denounced the evolution of birds as "fake."

The display is one of many traveling shows put on by the Foundation for Scientific Research, an Islamic creationist group that has become a household name in Turkey. Now, the groups says it is distributing its books — published in 59 languages including Arabic, Chinese, Swahili, and Polish — to 80 countries.

"Turkey is now the headquarters of creationism in the Islamic World. This is no longer only Turkey's problem, it is now the problem of the whole civilized world," says Haluk Ertan, a professor of molecular biology at Istanbul University. He's one of a handful of Turkish scientists who have been working to counter creationism's spread in the country.

Emboldened by its success at home over the past decade, the foundation, known by its Turkish acronym BAV (for Bilim Arastirma Vakfi), is now aggressively trying to export its unique brand of Islamic creationism well beyond the borders of Turkey to the Middle East, Europe, and even the United States.

In the past year, BAV has blanketed several European countries and the US with its glossy "Atlas of Creation," a lavish 768-page tome weighing more than 13 pounds, sending it to scientists, professors, journalists, and schoolteachers.

One member of the organization estimates that it distributed well over 20,000 copies of the "Atlas," which, like all of the group's books, is written under the name of Harun Yahya. Amazon.com hosts a virtual bookstore that sells "Atlas" ($99) and other Yahya books, and booksellers across Europe have it on their shelves.

"Every Islamic bookshop I know of stocks Harun Yahya's material. It is so glossily produced. It is very attractive and very colorful and outclasses everything else," says Inayat Bunglawala, assistant secretary-general of the Muslim British Council, speaking by phone from London.

"It is having an effect. Even among Muslim medical students there are a number now who are speaking out against Darwin."

In France, the Harun Yahya book offensive led the government to issue a warning for schools to be on the look out for the "Atlas" before it makes it into their classrooms. Meanwhile, the increasing European activity of the BAV, as well as of Christian creationist groups, recently prompted a committee of the Council of Europe — a 47-nation group that acts as a kind of continental watchdog — to issue a report strongly warning about its dangers to education.

"Today, creationists of all faiths are trying to get their ideas accepted in Europe. As a result, we have seen several initiatives from these various movements on the Eurasian continent in the last few years, with schools apparently the main target," the report, released in June, said.

Blames Darwinism for terrorism

In real life, Harun Yahya is a 51-year-old former interior-design student named Adnan Oktar. Since founding the BAV in 1990, Mr. Oktar has been responsible for ushering more than 250 books into print, though many observers agree he serves more as the chief overseer of a group of writers rather than as a solo author. The series includes titles such as "The Dark Spell of Darwinism" and "Why Darwinism is Incompatible with the Koran."

Oktar's brand of creationism is not only religious, but also political and even messianic, seeing most of the world's ills — terrorism and fascism among them — as stemming from Darwin's theory of evolution.

"Hitler, Mao, and Lenin were Darwinists. At the root of wild capitalism is also Darwinism. I think if we no longer believe in Darwinism, people will no longer be conditioned to believe in those things," the normally reclusive Oktar said during a recent press conference, held aboard a hired yacht cruising Istanbul's Bosphorus strait.

"Folks, there is no such thing as what you call evolution. If there was, it would be in the Holy Bible or the Koran," added Oktar, dressed in an ivory-white raw silk suit and wearing gold cufflinks and a matching gold belt buckle with Arabic inscriptions on them.

"The sweet dream of the Darwinists and the world is to ban my books," Oktar said, sipping glass after glass of sour cherry juice. "What I'm saying is true. They cannot disprove it."

Unlike fundamentalist Christian creationists, Oktar does not claim the earth was created only a few thousand years ago. Instead, he argues that fossils show that creatures from millions of years ago looked just like the creatures of today, thus disproving evolution.

Harmonizing modernity, Islam

While giving creationism a scientific veneer, "Scientifically speaking, the whole Harun Yahya corpus is a bunch of nonsense, but it is unfortunately very popular," says Taner Edis, a Turkish physicist who teaches at Truman State University in Missouri.

Professor Edis says the success of the Harun Yahya books, at least in the Islamic world, can be attributed to a need for harmonizing modern life with traditional Islamic beliefs.

"Something has to reconcile these two things and it becomes very attractive when someone comes out with a well-packaged message, that they can have both — be fully modern and at the same have science … affirm most of their very deeply held religious and ethical perceptions," says Edis, whose "An Illusion of Harmony: Science and Religion in Islam" was published by Prometheus Books this spring.

"That's a pretty attractive package and that's mostly what the Harun Yahya material provides," he says.

In Turkey, Oktar and his books certainly appear to be having an impact. When Science magazine conducted a survey of 34 countries last August, Turkey had the second-lowest acceptance rate of the theory of evolution (the United States had the lowest).

Creationist curriculum since '85

Creationism has actually been a part of the Turkish science curriculum since 1985, when it was added by government order, and many scientists now fear that it will soon be too hard to uproot.

"The general state of science education is very bad in the sense that evolution and creationism are taught together, and they can't be taught together. If they are, no scientific thinking can be established in these students," says Aykut Kence, a professor of biology at Ankara's Middle East Technical University.

"We are going to fall behind the modern countries in terms of development, economy, culture. Everything."

Comments 1 - 23 of 23 |

Reload Comments | Back to Top | Page Numbers

1. Comment #61044 by Rtambree on August 3, 2007 at 12:09 pm

 avatarTeaching lies and ignorance is a form of child abuse

Other Comments by Rtambree

2. Comment #61062 by Diplo on August 3, 2007 at 1:53 pm

 avatarWell, you have to admire their sheer audacity at blaming Darwinism for terrorism. That takes some nerve! Or should that be Shia audacity? ;)

It would be interesting to lock up some Christian fundies and Islamic fundies in a room and see how the debate went (after throwing away the key, of course...!)

Other Comments by Diplo

3. Comment #61067 by Duff on August 3, 2007 at 2:10 pm

If the Turks don't believe in evolution, they will become believers when they watch the evolution of their somewhat advanced country into another Afghanistan. The power of religion and creationism to transform a forward thinking country into a 12th century backwater will be very interesting to watch.

Other Comments by Duff

4. Comment #61069 by Freelance Scientist on August 3, 2007 at 2:12 pm

 avatar"Folks, there is no such thing as what you call evolution. If there was, it would be in the Holy Bible or the Koran," added Oktar.

Well that just about sums it up. Sad times indeed.

Other Comments by Freelance Scientist

5. Comment #61071 by troodon on August 3, 2007 at 2:14 pm

Where does this guy get his funding - Saudi?

Other Comments by troodon

6. Comment #61074 by genius2687 on August 3, 2007 at 2:17 pm

Evolution is generally not accepted in Islam. But it does seem like Old Earth Creationism is more popular than Young Earth Creationism than compared to the Christian counterpart.

Other Comments by genius2687

7. Comment #61083 by tieInterceptor on August 3, 2007 at 2:35 pm

 avatarthat could help us, if the Radical Muslims promote Intelligent design, this is going to ring some bells to a few people.

like when your parent like a rock band, automatically stops being cool ;)

Other Comments by tieInterceptor

8. Comment #61115 by genius2687 on August 3, 2007 at 5:44 pm

Hahaha

It would be a hilarious watching these left wing Multiculturalists trying to justify Islamic creationism in schools.

They'd be like "Well we need to respect everyones beliefs and we don't want to make Muslims feel offended and ailenated. So let's teach intelligent design alongside evolution so that we can be more tolerant and lower the number of extremists by making Muslims feel more included in society".

Other Comments by genius2687

9. Comment #61136 by BAEOZ on August 3, 2007 at 8:34 pm

 avatarA part of me smirks that their going backward. Good education and science are essential for a country to remain healthy and not fall into decay. Idiots.
But then I think, they're people, and it's sad that by being born in dogmatic societies they'll effectively be condemned to wallow. Of course, they'll then turn around and see prosperous, educated countries and think to themselves why doesn't their god, who holds them so dear, give them prosperity? Then they'll start the suicide bombs to soothe their damaged egos..... Too gloomy?

Other Comments by BAEOZ

10. Comment #61143 by pewkatchoo on August 3, 2007 at 11:45 pm

 avatarHo hum. Let's spread a little ignorance and stupidity. This puts the lie to the myth that Islam was ever an enlightened religion. There can be no such thing.

Other Comments by pewkatchoo

11. Comment #61145 by Johan on August 4, 2007 at 12:00 am

Imdat! Bu Orta Dogudan gelen aptalliga karsi koyma yapalim!

Other Comments by Johan

12. Comment #61149 by logical on August 4, 2007 at 12:41 am

 avatarWhy is anyone astonished?
Religion = religion = nonsense.
The next version (islamic this time) was to be expected - or should I become a professional prophet for asking "When will creationists crop up in islam?" about a year ago?
Is there a hindu or buddhist version out yet?
By the way: Is this the one with the glossy pictures?
How do I obtain my copy - in whichever language, I do not care, I will not read it.

Other Comments by logical

13. Comment #61152 by scottishgeologist on August 4, 2007 at 12:48 am

 avatarDiplo, re your comment:

It would be interesting to lock up some Christian fundies and Islamic fundies in a room and see how the debate went (after throwing away the key, of course...!)


Actually, they would have so much in common, as long as they stuck to oppression of women, hatred of gays, hatred of music, dance, nightclubs, enjoying yourself etc. lots of discussion of creationism, evils of EVILution and science, oh yes, opression of women (yeah, I know I mentioned it, but its so important to these f*cktards, it would definitely come up a second or 3rd time). Oh yes, and killing. Lots of it. Esp those who dare to disagree. Blow them up or invade their countries, the chorus would go.

Like you say throw the key away. And soundproof the whole thing. The rest of the world could then party in safety.

Mines a beer, cheers!
SG

Other Comments by scottishgeologist

14. Comment #61163 by Jesse. on August 4, 2007 at 2:08 am

You can laugh this off as anonther example of religious stupidity but I think there's a more general problem here.

The proponents of atheďsm, rationalism and evolution normally make rational arguments targeted at an intellectual and reasonably intelligent audience. Even the god delusion, RD's book that is the easiest to read, is aimed at such an audience. A lot of people however are not that intelligent. I can see the tactics of this foundation for 'scientific research' and more generally, the sheer stupidity and rethoric of priests, imams, etc. be far more effective with the less intelligent part of the population than the tactics of the prominent atheďsts.

This is not to say that RD or any of the others should change their tactics but there would be a place in our 'atheďstic movement' for something aimed at the less intelligent and/or educated part of the population. Something simple, easy and in your face, like the religious do, except off course they're lying and we wouldn't be :-)

The rational response squad seems tot do some work on this part on you tube with clear and very simple arguments against creationism and other stuff but this sort of thing seems to me not to happen enough on a global scale. Maybe we should try more to fight the religious on their own turf. I don't no exactly how yet, but I'm thinking something like billboards and stuff. I'd like to know what others think about this.

Other Comments by Jesse.

15. Comment #61174 by xyz on August 4, 2007 at 3:18 am

Only the (impending) cure for human mortality will exterminate God. Science will finally attain the status of God when it finds a cure for death because the most powerful glue that binds people to their Gods is their fear of death and the 'afterlife'. I am guessing this will happen in the next 50 years.

Other Comments by xyz

16. Comment #61207 by Tyler Durden on August 4, 2007 at 7:11 am

 avatar
When Science magazine conducted a survey of 34 countries last August, Turkey had the second-lowest acceptance rate of the theory of evolution (the United States had the lowest)

Incredible!! And yet so very sad. What are children in the U.S. being taught in schools? If there were any evidence needed for how religion poisons the mind, this is it.

Other Comments by Tyler Durden

17. Comment #61213 by liberalartist on August 4, 2007 at 7:41 am

 avatarAmericans are taught very little science in schools. Evolution is an avoided topic in many classrooms. I work with a lot of students who want to go into science in college but they are extremely underprepared and can't pass the basic courses. Some of them eventually figure out they were robbed of a good education the previous 12 years.

Sometimes I feel like the world is drifting into a new dark age where intellect and reason are banished for religious mania. The medical, humanistic, and political progress we have made as human beings is in jeopardy.

Other Comments by liberalartist

18. Comment #61239 by jefft0 on August 4, 2007 at 10:01 am

"What I'm saying is true. They cannot disprove it."

For the millionth time, "they cannot disprove it" does not mean "what I'm saying is true". However, "they cannot disprove it" does mean "what I'm saying cannot be tested" so a huckster like this can trick people into believing it's true.



Other Comments by jefft0

19. Comment #61428 by JanChan on August 5, 2007 at 6:13 am

Ok, I'm at a lost at some of the things written/said:

"Folks, there is no such thing as what you call evolution. If there was, it would be in the Holy Bible or the Koran,"
"he argues that fossils show that creatures from millions of years ago looked just like the creatures of today, thus disproving evolution."

All I can do is return a very blank stare that questions the guy's intelligence

Other Comments by JanChan

20. Comment #61551 by Nails on August 5, 2007 at 5:44 pm

 avatar
"Hitler, Mao, and Lenin were Darwinists. At the root of wild capitalism is also Darwinism. I think if we no longer believe in Darwinism, people will no longer be conditioned to believe in those things,"

But it will not be enough to prove it isn't the truth....
A quarter of the UK follows their horoscopes, it doesn't make them true either.
wild capitalism = Darwinism - I would love to see some evidence for this.
But this guy doesn't do evidence, obviously.
Sad, sad state of affairs.

Other Comments by Nails

21. Comment #61752 by Goldy on August 6, 2007 at 6:13 pm

 avatarFrom Arab News, another Islamic view. Have to say this one makes more sense :-)
http://www.arabnews.com/?page=5&section=0&article=99363&d=7&m=8&y=2007&pix=islam.jpg&category=Islam

Other Comments by Goldy

22. Comment #62070 by kwhitefoot on August 8, 2007 at 5:05 am

 avatarI'm not sure that Arab News page is as sensible as you think. At least as expressed in English it is downright contradictory.

Take this quotation for instance:
-quote
A. A married couple are not allowed to have sexual intercourse when the woman is in her period, or during postnatal discharge. What is not allowed is the actual intercourse. The reader asks about physical relations, but it should be clear that physical relations are allowed during these restricted times as long as they remain short of sexual intercourse. Hugging, kissing, cuddling and foreplay are all allowed.
-end quote
Sounds like they are paraphrasing some official doctrine but then they quote an English translation of the Koran:

-quote
"They ask you about menstruation. Say: 'It is an unclean condition; so keep aloof from women during menstruation, and do not draw near to them until they are cleansed. ... (2: 222)
-end quote
If you are enjoined to be aloof from women you would hardly be expected to kiss or cuddle them. AskOxford (http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/aloof?view=uk)says:
aloof
• adjective cool and distant.
Even if distant is interpreted metaphorically rather than physically it would surely not include foreplay! And anyway the Koran goes on to say "do not draw near them". How is that to be construed as allowing any physical contact?

Other Comments by kwhitefoot

23. Comment #271806 by perseid on October 26, 2008 at 3:36 pm

It's interesting to note that all the men and women who gather around Adnan Oktar are very attractive, tall and handsome. I personally went to one of the first Adnan Hodja's conferences. (In Turkey, Adnan Oktar is rather known as Adnan Hodja which means something like a sect leader.) There were very handsome model-type men all around. Conclusion: Adnan Oktar is a Darwinist subconsciously. He selects and employs only handsome people.

Other Comments by perseid
Reload Comments | Back to Top

Comment Entry: Please Login

Register a new account

Username:

Password:

Send a letter to the editor of the original media outlet.
CLICK HERE