Cheney and Obama: It's Not Genetic
By NICHOLAS WADE
Added: Sun, 21 Oct 2007 23:00:00 UTC
Reposted from:
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/21/weekinreview/21basic.html?ref=science
Two curious political relationships of Senator Barack Obama came to light last month in The Chicago Sun-Times: he is an 11th cousin to President Bush, and a 9th cousin once removed to Vice President Dick Cheney. The Bush-Obama ancestors are Samuel and Sarah Soole Hinckley of 17th-century Massachusetts, The Sun-Times wrote; the Cheney-Obama ancestors are Mareen and Susannah Duvall, 17th-century immigrants from France.
The story sent new ripples through the political world last week when Lynne Cheney repeated Mr. Obama's link with her husband in a television interview promoting her new book. It's not as if Mr. Bush and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad were found to be identical twins separated at birth; still, the genealogy was incongruous.
But the Bush-Obama-Cheney nexus means rather less than it may seem. Conventional genealogies conceal how rapidly genes get diluted down the generations. You inherit directly only half of your father's genes, a quarter of each grandfather's, an eighth of any great-grandfather's. And with ancestors much further back, you may share no more genes than you do with a random stranger met in Times Square.
That may be why many people cannot trace their family tree very far back: perhaps intuitively, they realize they don't share much, genetically speaking, with those distant forebears.
Tracing ancestry through the father's surname, a surrogate for the Y chromosome, may seem absurd given that the Y carries just 70 of the 25,000 or so genes in the human genome. But the compilers of Burke's Peerage could be engaged in a quest less ludicrous than it might sound. In in-bred populations like Europe's nobility, just as in isolated villages, everyone dips from the same little gene pool. In such cases, you inherit only half of your father's genes directly, but of the half that got left on the cutting-room floor, some may have come to you via your mother, who shared them with your father via a joint ancestor.
But in out-bred populations, like that of the United States, where people generally marry people who are not related to them in any known way, genes get diluted really fast. Mr. Obama probably inherited a minute fraction — one divided by two to the 11th power — of Mareen Duvall's genome, which would amount to less than one gene, assuming the Y chromosome was not inherited. Much the same would be true of Mr. Cheney. The chance that they inherited the same one gene is vanishingly small. So the fact of their genealogical relationship, whatever its political symbolism, is genetically meaningless.
Tweet
RELATED CONTENT
Dolan: White House is “strangling”...
- - Preserve Religious Freedom -... 23 Comments
Dolan: White House is “strangling” Catholic church
Katherine Stewart - The Guardian 38 Comments
Christian-nationalist zealots are trying to rewrite US history, airbrush slavery and enshrine creationism in Texas schools
Frank Bruni - The New York Times 29 Comments
The Right’s Righteous Frauds
Nonbelievers flex their political...
Kimberly Winston - Religion News... 9 Comments
One of the biggest growth areas in political activism around religion is coming from an unlikely source: the nonreligious.
Queen 'should remain Defender of the...
Alex Strangwayes-Booth - BBC News 65 Comments
"... if you disestablish the Church and disconnect the Church from the monarchy, it gives the impression there are almost no values we share in common at all."
'Save the planet', science leaders urge...
Pallab Ghosh - BBC News - Science &... 35 Comments
MORE BY NICHOLAS WADE
Anthropology Group Tries to Soothe...
Nicholas Wade - nytimes.com 17 Comments
Depth of the Kindness Hormone Appears...
Nicholas Wade - The New York Times 19 Comments
Deciphering the Chatter of Monkeys and...
Nicholas Wade - New York Times 13 Comments
Disease Cause Is Pinpointed With Genome
Nicholas Wade - New York Times 12 Comments
Human Culture, an Evolutionary Force
Nicholas Wade - New York Times 57 Comments




















Comments
Comment RSS Feed
Please sign in or register to comment
View Comments Page