What's the evolutionary advantage of offering your place to an old woman on a bus?

Thanks to braininthevat for the suggestion.

Rhetorical questions like this are used as an attempt to poke holes in the evolutionary explanation of morality, in the same way creationists or ID-ists look for "irreducible complexity" in biology.

Use the comment space below to present your rebuttal. Let's try and be clear and concise, as if this were to be used in a debate.

Be sure to login and use our new "Rank this comment" feature (right under each comment while logged in) to help score your favorite responses. Comments can now be sorted by highest rank.

TAGGED: BEHAVIOR, EVOLUTION


RELATED CONTENT

Do kids have to be taught about the...

Thomas Rees - [epiphenom] the science... 47 Comments

Do kids have to be taught about the supernatural?

Mice sing to impress the girls,...

- - University of Veterinary... 16 Comments

The house mouse, spe­cies Mus mus­cu­lus. Male house mice pro­­duce me­lo­di­ous songs to at­­tract mates, not un­­like many birds, ac­­cord­ing to new re­search. (Im­age cour­te­sy Maine Dept. of Ag­ri­cul­ture)

Budgies find yawns irresistible too

- - NewScientist 4 Comments

Budgies find yawns irresistible too

Can you really be addicted to the...

Polly Curtis - The Guardian 26 Comments


Photograph: Peter Dazeley/Getty Images
Can you really be addicted to the internet?

Chimpanzees consider their audience...

Victoria Gill - BBC Nature 8 Comments

Orangutans 'could video chat' between...

Dave Lee - BBC News 21 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment