By MICHAEL RUSE - GUARDIAN.CO.UK
Added: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 00:00:00 UTC

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/belief/2009/nov/02/atheism-dawkins-ruse

As a professional philosopher my first question naturally is: "What or who is an atheist?" If you mean someone who absolutely and utterly does not believe there is any God or meaning then I doubt there are many in this group. Richard Dawkins denies being such a person. If you mean someone who agrees that logically there could be a god, but who doesn't think that the logical possibility is terribly likely, or at least not something that should keep us awake at night, then I guess a lot of us are atheists. But there is certainly a split, a schism, in our ranks. I am not whining (in fact I am rather proud) when I point out that a rather loud group of my fellow atheists, generally today known as the "new atheists", loathe and detest my thinking. Richard Dawkins has likened me to the pusillanimous appeaser at Munich, Neville Chamberlain. Jerry Coyne, author of Why Evolution is True, says (echoing Orwell) that only someone with pretensions to the intelligentsia could believe the silly things I believe. And energetic blogger PZ Myers refers to me as a "clueless gobshite" because I confessed to seeing why true believers might find the Kentucky Creationist Museum convincing. I will spare you what my fellow philosopher Dan Dennett has to say about me.

There are several reasons why we atheists are squabbling – I will speak only for myself but I doubt I am atypical. First, non-believer though I may be, I do not think (as do the new atheists) that all religion is necessarily evil and corrupting. This claim is on a par with golden plates in upstate New York. The Quakers and the Evangelicals were inspired and driven by their religion to oppose slavery, and a good thing too. Of course there has been evil in the name of religion – the pope telling Africans not to use condoms in the face of Aids – but as often as not religion is not the only or even the primary force for evil. The troubles in Northern Ireland were surely about socio-economic issues also, and the young men who flew into the World Trade Centre towers were infected by the alienation and despair of the young in Muslim countries in the face of poverty and inequalities.
...
Continue reading
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/belief/2009/nov/02/atheism-dawkins-ruse
_______________________________________________________________
[UPDATE] PZ and Jerry Coyne post comments on this as well

Schisms, rifts, and apologia for insanity
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2009/11/schisms_rifts_and_apologia_for.php

Ruse gibbers on...
http://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2009/11/02/ruse-gibbers-on/

TAGGED: ATHEISM, COMMENTARY