Tilting at symbols

Q: What's your reaction to Sunday's decision by voters in Switzerland to ban construction of minarets, the slender towers from which Muslims are called to daily prayers?

"This was a vote against minarets as symbols of Islamic power," said the General Secretary of the Swiss People's Party, which had proposed the referendum. And therein lies the problem: when we turn our energies to fighting symbols rather than dealing with the real underlying issues, we are invariably going to miss our target.

I have some sympathy with the 57% of Swiss who voted in favor of the ban: analysts are no doubt correct when they attribute the vote to concern about rising levels of immigration and, with it, rising levels of Islam in a country which has traditionally been rather inward-looking and self-contained. The Swiss can have drawn precious little comfort from the experiences of other European countries, where a blind devotion to multiculturalism has led to the creation of cultural ghettos, when what was really needed was a concerted effort to fully integrate immigrants into our respective societies.

Read More
-----------
http://newsweek.washingtonpost.com/onfaith/panelists/paula_kirby/2009/12/tilting_at_symbols.html

TAGGED: COMMENTARY, RELIGION


RELATED CONTENT

Secular Guidelines to Moral Living: A...

Jeff Schweitzer - Huffington Post 35 Comments

So, in honor of Hitchens I propose here guidelines to how we can make those daily decisions, a secular distillation of moral behavior derived from those characteristics that define us as human.

The atheist who tried to steal Christmas

Larry Taunton - USA Today 70 Comments

Christmas is, after all, the season of magic, and lest children confuse sugar plum fairies and flying reindeer with the observable and repeatable, the professor has loaded neither toys nor goodies on his sleigh but a heavy dose of "rational skepticism."

Searching under the lamp-post

Richard Dawkins - RichardDawkins.net 89 Comments

I suspect that there is life elsewhere in the universe, but it is probably extremely rare and isolated on far-flung islands of life, like a celestial Polynesia.

Evolution, Christmas and the Atonement

Denis Alexander - The Guardian... 59 Comments

We are not descended from Adam and Eve – but still, Jesus was born to save us.

Turin Shroud resurrected

Richard Dawkins - RichardDawkins.net 351 Comments

The new 'evidence' amounts to yet another 'Argument from Personal Incredulity': the Italian scientists cannot understand how it could have been faked.

Americans: Undecided About God?

Eric Weiner - New York Times 59 Comments

Nones don’t get hung up on whether a religion is “true” or not, and instead subscribe to William James’s maxim that “truth is what works.”

MORE

MORE BY PAULA KIRBY

‘How do atheists find meaning in life?’

Paula Kirby - Washington Post On Faith 189 Comments

Life cannot be meaningless so long as we have the capacity to affect the well-being of ourselves and others. For true meaninglessness, we would need heaven.

Evolution threatens Christianity

Paula Kirby - Washington Post On Faith 293 Comments

Christianity is like a big, chunky sweater. It may feel cozy, it may keep you warm, but just let one stitch be dropped and the whole thing unravels before your very eyes. Evolution is that stitch.

Spirituality: It’s only human

Paula Kirby - Washington Post - On... 50 Comments

Religion is a parasite that feeds on all that is good in humanity as a whole and then proclaims it as its own gift to the world.

Rick Perry and the scandal of prayer

Paula Kirby - Washington Post - On... 39 Comments

There is no magic friend. There is only us. We are not perfect, we are not all-powerful, we are not infallible; but we are all we have.

Breaking Out from the Prison of Religion

Paula Kirby - The Hibernia Times 135 Comments

Atheism is the true embrace of reality

Paula Kirby - Hibernia Times 97 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment