The Guardian tries to pwn Dawkins

In his blog On Art in today’s Guardian, Johnathan Jones, whoever he is, makes an invidious and ill-informed comparison between Dawkins and Darwin: “Natural selection: Give me Darwin over Dawkins any day.“

To Jones, Darwin was the moderate Victorian gentleman, presenting evidence without bashing creationism, while Dawkins (of course) is strident and arrogant, putting off his biology audience off by touting atheism. This is Mooneyism at its best:

Darwin is the finest fruit of English empiricism. His modest presentation of evidence contrasts, I am sorry to say, with the rhetorical stridency of Richard Dawkins. Visit the famous atheist’s website and you will see two causes being pushed. Dawkins is campaigning with other secular stars against the pope’s visit to Britain. Meanwhile he is touring the paperback of his book The Greatest Show On Earth: The Evidence for Evolution. The trouble with this book is that it lacks Darwin’s empirical style. Where the Victorian writer presented masses of evidence, and let his astonishing, earth-shattering theory emerge from common-sense observations of nature, Dawkins lacks the patience, at this point in his career, to let natural history speak for itself. He has become the mirror image of the theological dogmatists he despises.

He just can’t separate science from the debate he has got into with religious people.

I don’t know what book Jones read, but it’s not the same one I reviewed in The Nation. The Greatest Show on Earth has chapter after chapter of solid biology, natural history, genetics, evo-devo, and the like. Yes, Dawkins takes some slaps at creationists, but Darwin wasn’t dealing with a 150-year history of entrenched religious opposition to his ideas.

Read on

TAGGED: ACCOMMODATIONISM, DARWIN, RICHARD DAWKINS


RELATED CONTENT

The Descent of Edward Wilson

Richard Dawkins - Prospect 47 Comments

Richard Dawkins's review of The Social Conquest of Earth, by Edward O Wilson (WW Norton, £18.99, May)

The beauty of creation: an interview...

Heather Catchpole - COSMOS Magazine 13 Comments

The beauty of creation: an interview with Richard Dawkins
COSMOS Managing Editor, Heather Catchpole, caught up with Richard Dawkins to discuss evolution, the origin of life and his plans for his next book.

Moral Clarity and Richard Dawkins

Carson - Reasons for God 92 Comments

What kind of meta-ethical foundation has Dawkins provided for his ‘moral home’?

No blood on the carpet. How...

Richard Dawkins - RichardDawkins.net 173 Comments

[Journalists] seem to feel let down when they discover that the real people aren't anything like the way they so relentlessly portray us; as if, since they've gone to the trouble of inventing extravagant caricatures of us, we should at least have the decency to live up to them in real life.
Also in Polish

UPDATED: Why I want all our children to...

Richard Dawkins - The Observer 179 Comments

Whatever else the Bible might be – and it really is a great work of literature – it is not a moral book and young people need to learn that important fact because they are very frequently told the opposite.

Richard Dawkins - US October 2012 Tour

- - RichardDawkins.net 27 Comments

MORE

MORE BY JERRY COYNE

Science, Religion and Society: The...

Jerry Coyne - Evolution 0 Comments

Jerry Coyne's paper on the relationship between acceptance of evolution, religion, and societal health, available for free download.

Mencken week: Day 2

Jerry Coyne - Why Evolution Is True 11 Comments

Robert Wright promotes...

Jerry Coyne - Why Evolution Is True 204 Comments

Robert Wright promotes accommodationism, disses Dawkins

Sean Faircloth talks about Catholicism...

Jerry Coyne - Why Evolution Is True 9 Comments

Sean Faircloth talks about Catholicism at Notre Dame

Happy Darwin Day!

Jerry Coyne - Why Evolution Is True 19 Comments


Happy Darwin Day!

“Only a theory”???

Jerry Coyne - Why Evolution Is True 42 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment