Beyond the Believers

Thanks to George Hyde for the link.

Reposted from:
http://www.secularhumanism.org/index.php?section=library&page=harris_27_2

Recently, I attended a three-day conference at the Salk Institute, organized by The Science Network. The conference was titled, Beyond Belief: Science, Religion, Reason, and Survival and was conducted as a town-hall meeting before an audience of invited guests. Speakers included Steven Weinberg, Harold Kroto, Richard Dawkins, and many other scientists and philosophers who have been, and remain, energetic opponents of religious unreason. And then there were other esteemed participants and audience members who proved themselves to be eager purveyors of American-style religious bewilderment.

It was a room full of bright, scientifically literate people—molecular biologists, anthropologists, physicists, engineers—and yet, three days were insufficient to force agreement on whether or not there is any conflict between religion and science. While at Salk, I witnessed scientists giving voice to some of the most unctuous religious apologies I have ever heard. It is one thing to be told that the pope is a great champion of reason and that his opposition to embryonic stem cell research has nothing to do with religious dogmatism; it is quite another to be told this by a Stanford physician who sits on the President's Council on Bioethics. Over the course of the meeting, I had the pleasure of hearing that Hitler, Stalin, and Mao were examples of secularism run amok, that the doctrines of martyrdom and jihad have nothing whatsoever to do with Muslim terrorism, that people can never be argued out of their beliefs because we live in an irrational world, that science has made no important contributions to our ethical lives, and that it is not the job of scientists "to take away people's hope"—all from atheist scientists, happily trading in the most abject and paralyzing shibboleths of academic political correctness. There were several moments during our panel discussions that brought to mind the final scene of Invasion of the Body Snatchers—people who looked like scientists, had published as scientists, and would soon be returning to their labs nevertheless gave voice to the alien hiss of religious lunacy at the slightest prodding. In case anyone thought that the front lines in our culture wars could be found at the entrance to a megachurch, I am here to report that we still have considerable work to do in a nearby trench.

For all the frustration I felt at this meeting, it seemed like the perfect forum in which to resolve the centuries-old collision between reason and faith. If reputable scientists cannot be made to agree that there are important intellectual and moral differences between knowing something and pretending to know it, we are doomed. Happily, the meeting at Salk will be convened again next fall. Perhaps then it will be possible to rule out the Virgin Birth of Jesus as a valid scientific hypothesis.

While I heard many silly retorts to atheism at this conference, here is a list of those most in need of deflation by freethinkers:

1. Even though I'm an atheist, my friends are atheists, and we all get along fine without pretending to know that one of our books was written by the Creator of the universe, other people really do need religion. It is, therefore, wrong to criticize their faith.

2. People are not really motivated by religion. Religion is used as a rationale for other aims—political, economic, and social. Consequently, the specific content of religious doctrines is beside the point.

3. It is useless to argue against the veracity of religious doctrines, because religious people are not actually making claims about reality. Their claims are metaphorical or otherwise without real content. Hence, there is no conflict between religion and science.

4. Religion will always be with us. The idea that we might rid ourselves of it to any significant degree is quixotic, bordering on delusional. Dawkins and other strident opponents of religious faith are just wasting their time.


I invite readers of FREE INQUIRY to provide short answers to any or all of these fantasies. The winning responses will be published in a future issue of the magazine. Winners in each category will be sent signed copies of both of my books and a cash prize of $100. Each response must be two hundred words or less (longer responses will be disqualified). Correspondence should be sent to: Free Inquiry Contest, P.O. Box 664, Amherst, NY 14226-0664.

Sam Harris is the author of The New York Times bestsellers, The End of Faith and Letter to a Christian Nation.

trench

TAGGED: ACCOMMODATIONISM, RELIGION, SCIENCE


RELATED CONTENT

12 Visualizations That Will Change the...

Drew Skau - visual.ly 19 Comments

The Scale of the Universe by Cary and Michael Huang. This version has an interactive slider and lets you scroll through the zoom levels yourself.

Alzheimer's brain plaques 'rapidly...

James Gallagher - BBC Health 19 Comments

"This is an unprecedented finding. Previously, the best existing treatment for Alzheimer's disease in mice required several months to reduce plaque in the brain."

Gene therapy 'gave me sight back'

Helen Briggs - BBC News - Health 15 Comments

Three US citizens who lost their sight in childhood have reported a dramatic improvement in vision after having gene therapy in both eyes.

Zebra stripes evolved to keep biting...

Victoria Gill - BBC Nature 29 Comments


Zebra stripes evolved to keep biting flies at bay

America and Eurasia 'to meet at north...

Neil Bowdler - BBC News Science &... 15 Comments

America and Eurasia will crash into each other over the North Pole in 50-200 million years time, according to scientists at Yale University.

Rare Martian meteorite given to science

Anna-Marie Lever, Jonathan Amos - BBC... 6 Comments

"It is as if it has just been blasted off Mars. It is effectively a pristine sample of Mars."

MORE

MORE BY SAM HARRIS

Your God is My God What Mitt Romney...

Sam Harris - The Blog 3 Comments

Your God is My God What Mitt Romney Could Say to Win the Republican Nomination

Everything and Nothing - An Interview...

Sam Harris - The Sam Harris Blog 23 Comments


Everything and Nothing - An Interview with Lawrence Krauss

Lying

Sam Harris - Amazon - Kindle edition 120 Comments

September 11, 2011

Sam Harris - SamHarris.org 142 Comments

What defenders of religion cannot say is that anyone has ever gone berserk, or that a society ever failed, because people became too reasonable, intellectually honest, or unwilling to be duped by the dogmatism of their neighbors.

Whither Eagleman?

Sam Harris - SamHarris.org 20 Comments

Part 1 (we hope) of a written exchange between Sam Harris and David Eagleman.

Ask Sam Harris Anything #2

Sam Harris - www.samharris.org 337 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment