By JOHN BINGHAM AND TIM ROSS - THE TELEGRAPH
Added: Fri, 17 Feb 2012 22:03:59 UTC

This article was posted after a posting from earlier today which is the same internview/poll from a different source. The comments from both have been combined and the previous article is reposted below

Faith rules 'end at temple door', equalities chief says

BBC
Christians must choose between their religion and obeying the law, according to Trevor Phillips, the human rights watchdog.

Trevor Phillips: Religious rules should end “at the door of the temple” and give way to the “public law” laid down by Parliament Photo: REX

He declared that Christians who want to be exempt from equality legislation are like Muslims trying to impose sharia.

Religious rules should end “at the door of the temple” and give way to the “public law” laid down by Parliament, the chairman of the Equality and Human Rights Commission said.

He argued that Roman Catholic adoption agencies and other faith groups providing public services must choose between their religion and obeying the law when their beliefs conflict with the will of the state.

Mr Phillips singled out the adoption agencies that fought a long legal battle to avoid being forced to accept homosexual couples under equality laws. Last year, following a High Court case, the Charity Commission ruled against an exemption for Catholic Care, an adoption agency operating in Leeds.
Read more

Christians who argue they should be exempt from equality laws are no different from Muslims who want to impose sharia law in the UK, human rights chief Trevor Phillips has said.

He told a debate religious rules should lose sway "at the door of the temple".

Trevor Phillips is chairman of government body the Equality and Human Rights Commission

Christian adoption agencies and hotel owners have fought legal battles against rules requiring them to treat gay and straight people equally.

But Mr Phillips said those who provide a public service must abide by the law.

Catholic adoption agencies have objected to legislation which requires them not to discriminate between gay and straight couples on the grounds of sexuality when considering applications.

Last year, after a High Court case, the Charity Commission refused to grant an exemption for one Leeds-based agency, Catholic Care.

Disputes have also arisen where Christian bed and breakfast owners have turned away gay couples and subsequently been ordered to pay damages.

Mr Phillips, chairman of the Equality and Human Rights Commission, was speaking at a debate organised by the Religion and Society Research Programme.

Asked about conflicts between religion and equalities, he said: "The law stops at the door of the temple as far as I'm concerned.

"Once you start to provide public services that have to be run under public rules, for example child protection, then you have to go with public law.

"Institutions have to make a decision whether they want to do that or they don't want to do that, but you can't say 'because we decide we're different then we need a different set of laws'."

Read on

TAGGED: LAW, RELIGION