'Hell' as child-abuse
By MODERATOR
Added: Thu, 09 Sep 2010 20:40:47 UTC
[A letter submitted to Richard Dawkins, and reproduced here with the writer's permission. Slightly edited for clarity.]
Hi Mr Dawkins,
I've read two of your books: The God Delusion and The Selfish Gene, and I've found both of them brilliant. I'm an Italian girl, my name is Roberta and I'm just 19; sorry if my English is so bad.
My parents are smart and atheist people: my mother is a teacher and my father is a doctor. They love and support me every day and I've learnt to use my brain. Nevertheless, I've had some bad experiences with religion. When I was a child I attended, for some months, a Catholic school. My teacher was a nun and I have terrible memories of her: she had bad ways, she seemed to be always angry and she used to scream a lot with us, little children. Every morning I cried because I didn't want to go to school; so I went to a 'normal' school instead.
A few years later, I found myself having some contact with catechists, and sometimes I went to Church on Sunday. My little friends were religious and used their brains differently from me: when I was in a religious context, I always felt 'abused': catechists spoke to us about God's punishment, hell, and their words were not reassuring, but sad and scary.
When I was 8, I accidentally watched a program on Mtv: they talked about masturbation and they condemned it, saying that God punishes 'bad' people with hell. From that moment, I was never the same. I was scared every day, I got obsessive compulsive disorder; I' was terrified I would go to hell, I felt many years that I'd been 'abandoned' by God, and alone. I was just a child.
Now, things are quite different. I'm a 'healthy' brain-user!, but I'm still scared. The irrational part of my mind is still terrified, but I choose to use my brain. Now I am studying Biology at university: I'm smart and I think that Nature is simply beautiful. I choose to be free and brave, and your books help me to be a peaceful person. Every child should have the opportunity of choosing. I'd like to become a Neurophysiologist.
Thanks so much, Roberta.
Tweet
RELATED DISCUSSIONS
Geoffrey Robertson vs the Catholic...
martinpribble 17 Comments
Religious "Baby Throwing" in India
Tiende Landeplage 56 Comments
Dutch Roman Catholic Church Had Boys...
Schrodinger's Cat 32 Comments
The 'Witch Children' Condemned by...
xmaseveeve 97 Comments
How should we help adults deal with the...
mirandaceleste 34 Comments
MORE BY Moderator
Temporary glitch with starting...
Moderator 0 Comments
Moderator 271 Comments
Moderator 116 Comments



















Comments
Comment RSS Feed
Please sign in or register to comment
View Comments Page