Activity

Holmes: Only an explanation that does not rely in material quantities will work

Holmes: Every scientific explanation leverages material processes.

Therefore the origin of the material processes themselves must leverage material processes

if the explanation for them is to be a scientific one.

So smug, so self-sure.

It’s like you think the universe has to fit itself into your biased perspective.

Science is about doing the best we can with what we have, it pretends no omnipotence.  I say that because it sure seems like that’s what you keep demanding.   You’re more about head games and philosophizing about science, when science is about observing, studying, learning, accepting we’ll never figure it all out.

Others have done a more eloquent job of explaining that simply because the first moment of this universe might be out of our reach, does not invalidate the material world that’s grown out of that moment and that created all we are made out of.

😉 https://confrontingsciencecontrarians.blogspot.com/2018/09/key-to-gould-nonoverlapping-magisteria.html